Tougher penalties, not criminal charges

Posted on March 7th, 2008 in FIFA, Idiots, Injuries, discipline by stopsatgreen

Has Sepp Blatter ever come up with a good idea? Maybe I don’t know enough about the inner workings of FIFA, but I get the impression that Blatter is a bit of an idiot.

His latest idea may not be as ridiculous as his plan to force women footballers to play in skimpy clothing, but it’s pretty stupid nonetheless: lifetime bans and criminal prosecutions for dangerous tackles.

Don’t get me wrong; I’m not condoning dangerous play, and I think the current system of straight red cards earning the aggressor a three-match ban, regardless of the offence, is absurd. But lifetime bans are a nonsense. For a start, they depend on the interpretation; the recent tackle by Martin Taylor on Eduardo, for instance, was reckless and stupid, but was there an element of malice? If Eduardo’s foot hadn’t been planted the way it was, he wouldn’t have suffered the terrible injury; would that still be an offence worth ending Taylor’s career? A six match ban would be sufficient, as far as I’m concerned; we have to give players the chance to apologise and rehabilitate themselves.

And as for criminal charges, once you start down that road you’re opening yourselves up for a whole new era of litigation. If you set the precedent that tackles can lead to legal action, what’s to stop players suing other players if they feel they have been tackled unfairly? Or players suing managers for giving them instructions to be physical, which then lead to a player being banned for life?

Football needs to be a physical game, but it doesn’t have to be a dangerous one. No-one wants to see players facing potentially career-ending injuries, but the solution, in my opinion, is a mixture of the following ideas:

  • Referees to apply the letter of the law from the first whistle, not to let the first couple go free;
  • Longer bans for reckless or dangerous tackles;
  • Five minutes off the field after being given a caution for dangerous play, in order to let tempers cool;
  • Video panels to apply or extend punishments that the referee didn’t see or didn’t act upon sufficiently

Weekend thoughts - Arsenal, Eduardo and more

Posted on February 25th, 2008 in Idiots, Injuries, Premiership by Left back

Obviously the Eduardo incident is the one that most of the headlines have been generated about. Some thoughts in bullet point form.

  • I don’t think Taylor tried to break his leg, I do think Taylor tried ‘let him know he was there’. Both Taylor and Eduardo were unlucky.
  • Any player, manager or pundit who tries to say it wasn’t a red card is absolutely clueless.
  • The FA, so quick to dole out punishments for players who commit such outrageous acts as wearing Superman underpants or wearing a t-shirt with a message on it for when they score, must immediately introduce a system where acts of violent conduct can be punished more severely than a 3 game ban
  • Jeremie Aliadiere and Martin Taylor each miss the same number of games, punished as severely as each other yet the incidents are so far removed from each other in terms of seriousness it’s laughable
  • Arsene Wenger’s initial comments about Taylor being given a life ban were over the top and the Arsenal manager acknowledged that by retracting his statement. Yet pundits like David Platt, having viewed pictorial and video evidence, were unwilling to change their position. They complain about Wenger but at least he had the balls to come out and say he was wrong.
  • Websites that continued to report Wenger’s ‘life ban’ comments a full 24 hours after he had retracted them are pathetic
  • The lack of media condemnation for the dangerous tackle is worrying. You wonder if it had been a foreign player who shattered Wayne Rooney’s leg would the reaction have been the same

Hopefully Eduardo will make a full recovery and play again for Arsenal because he was beginning to show signs of being a real talent. Our best wishes to him.

Elsewhere in the Premier League. Cheerio Fulham, Newcastle are now flirting with relegation and so pathetic is their squad and their lack of fight they deserve to be right in the mire, Torres is the one bright spot in Liverpool’s season. Imagine how much they’d be struggling without him.

Paul Jewell will leave Derby at the end of the season, I reckon. I’ve never heard a manager so consitently negative about his team.

Carling Cup Final - dull as dishwater. Chelsea got what they deserved, which was nothing. With so many top class players they’re so very negative. I thought Grant was going to change all that. They wouldn’t have lost that final under Mourinho.

Anyway, your thoughts welcome as always.

“Oooh, yes that does look a bit sore actually…”

Posted on February 25th, 2008 in Injuries, Premiership by Chris

The thought suddenly struck me a few years ago that about a third of Arsenal’s goals come from offside positions. Not wishing to be the tit in the room pointing out that the actor’s voice is less than perfectly synched in with his mouth movements, I kept this to myself and endured a tough couple of years when the rest of the country were swooning over Arsene Wenger’s team, playing coyly with their hair whenever they were on television and whispering to each other about what a great shag they must be.I would drop hints sure, tentative and designed to encourage suspicion in others as opposed to crassly revealing the secret myself, but they weren’t conclusive enough, met with disinterested shrugs from all. “That not off…?” I would venture, leaving the “…side” absent, hoping the hanging pause would lead to somebody else posing the question, but the moment never came, my weak protests rendered spiteful and petty when weighed against the rest of the world’s infatuation. “Oh, but they’re wonderful aren’t they? Not just nice to look at but really lovely to talk to as well” appeared to be the nation’s consensus.

But I kept noticing and every time it happened it sapped away at my soul, a little bit more of me dying inside, the football equivalent of the rush hour commute or not having any milk left in the fridge and the tea already poured. Arsenal’s brand of football is to be encouraged, certainly, but at the expense of one of the fundamental rules? And Arsene Wenger noticed it as well, I’m bastard convinced he did, because every time he complained about a decision that hadn’t gone his team’s way, he let out a smirk: a smug satisfied flick of his lips, aimed squarely at me, invented sorely to encourage my irritation. “But your team is allowed to flaunt one of the game’s most crucial rules on an almost bi-matchly basis”, I stammered, my voice a wreck of quivering impotence and indignation. “Yeah, and what the fuck are you going to do about it?” he taunted me, from behind his two big and hard mates.

So I stopped watching them. Not that big of a deal really- Arsenal are of fine stock and have some great players, but their new stadium is charmless and distancing and their games run a similar pattern to 90% of the rest of the games involving the (oh Jesus, here it comes) ‘Big Four’ (ugh). Arsenal get an early goal and settle in, their opponents play alright, a little toothless maybe but never looking particularly overawed or mismatched, then Arsenal get a second goal and lots of tedious people whiter on about the hopeless gulf in quality in the Premiership and, oh dear, isn’t it terrible and, please, will somebody think of the children. It’s not a hard and fast science, of course, but if missing the occasional Adebayor happy slapping is the price I have to pay for not being enraged by their offside allowances to point of grim absolution- where I feel like the only solution is to grab one of the neighbourhood’s stray kittens and set it alight in a creepily mechanical way, all along explaining to it the bylaws and intricacies of one of football’s oldest laws, the occasional maniacal raising of my voice the only intrusion into the otherwise monotone and spookily delivered monologue- then it the least I can do. Fact: if Seven’s John Doe had never sat down to watch the ‘Best of Arsenal’ video clip on YouTube, Detective David Mills and his wife Tracy would now be raising their child in peaceful domestic harmony.

Because of all this I came into the Eduardo and Taylor incident at the weekend with an interesting perspective: denied the initial shock of witnessing it firsthand and confident on how these things get built up by people made it easier to sympathise with Taylor as well as Eduardo and I had my steely nerve armed and ready but the effect of seeing it happen was still a genuinely upsetting one. The most horrific thing was the almost shell-shocked reaction of Eduardo, his stunned call to the bench followed by immediate slump onto the ground reminded me a lot of the Solider at the beginning of ‘Saving Private Ryan’ looking to retrieve his detached arm in an almost dreamlike state. For someone like me, who cringes at the thought of catching his finger on the back gate, it was all deeply unpleasant.

The problem being, of course, that our righteous fury has been somewhat stumped by the fact that it wasn’t actually that nasty a challenge. In a season where various thugs have been doing whatever they can in the name of viral marketing for the new Rambo film, it seems unfortunate that this one will be the one we all remember. And though people pointing out that if had been a Croatian player doing that to Wayne Rooney the Queen herself would have broken Royal Protocol to register her disgust undoubtedly have a point I can’t help thinking the argument works both ways.

Look at the stills of the incident; compare Taylor’s stocky and unkempt frame to Eduardo lithe, athletic shape. Look at the names for Christ’s sake, Eduado evoking exotic images of passion and inhibition and cheap Easyjet packages if you book it now and don’t mind where you’re your flying from and Taylor, quintessentially English, the sheer antithesis of glamour. The whole incident is the exact opposite of poetry: it’s the destruction of the skilful and the beautiful and the hopelessly romantic dreamer by the functional and the ugly and the nightclub bouncer that doesn’t let you in because you’re mates got a vest on underneath his shirt. What we shouldn’t lose sight of, however, is the fact that none of this is especially Matt Taylor’s fault, he just happens to be really shit at playing football, whereas Eduado happens to be really good. Players have been forgiven more in the past.

If we are looking for someone to be rude at about the whole thing, we could do alot worse than Harry Rednapp who delivered a particularly crass and mistimed batch of his patterned casual racism on Saturday evening, jokingly reassuring the press that Kranjcar didn’t dive for his team’s penalty despite his “being Croatian”, as Croatian international Eduardo lay on a hospital bed somewhere in agonising pain, contemplating the end of his football career.

chrismackin.wordpress.com

It’s not the pitch

Posted on October 17th, 2007 in Idiots, Injuries, International by Left back

I love the way this morning’s tabloids have blamed the artificial pitch in Russia for John Terry’s injury. You’d swear these pitches were cement painted to look like grass or something.

I play on one every week and they’re brilliant. You can slide and not rip all your skin off, they’re bouncy and not hard on the legs at all and the surface is true which means no holes, divots, slopes or anything else.

Might it just be that Terry is increasingly injury prone? Might it be that Mourinho was right when he tried to get the Chelsea medical team to investigate the underlying problems, much to Terry’s dislike?

A ‘locked knee’ would have happened on a normal pitch too. As for the match, there’s no disadvantage in playing on this artificial pitch but you can be quite sure it will be used an excuse if England don’t get the right result tonight.

Would it be wrong…

Posted on October 11th, 2007 in Injuries, International by Left back

…to enjoy Michael Owen ripping a hamstring in two while playing for England?

Michael Owen is lucky he’s not a horse

Posted on September 26th, 2007 in Injuries by Left back

He’d have been put out to stud or to graze or whatever it is they do to old horses that are slow and useless.

They shoot some of them, don’t they?

Can of worms

Posted on September 5th, 2007 in Injuries, International, The FA by Left back

Steven Gerrard is struggling with a toe injury. England want to give him a pain killing injection so he can play in the Euro qualifiers.

Now, if I was Liverpool Football Club I’d recall Gerrard immediately and if the FA refused I would line up legal action should Gerrard miss games for his club because of the injection. Let’s remember, the injection will do nothing to help the injury heal. It will simply prevent Gerrard from feeling the pain and he could very easily do himself more damage because of it.

I know Gerrard is an important player but it’s completely wrong for the FA to put him at more risk for their own needs. They do not pay his wages therefore they should have no input or influence over how his injuries are treated.

Newcastle sued the FA over Michael Owen’s World Cup injury and that was a mere accident. If Gerrard spends time out on the back of what the England management team decide we could see a huge lawsuit and it would be right and proper too.

Ole, Ole Ole Ole

Posted on August 29th, 2007 in Football, Injuries by The Mac

While I am no Manchester United fan, I was a little disappointed to read of the enforced retirement of Ole Gunnar Solksjaer. This was a player who had an uncanny knack of scoring goals, especially from the bench – 126 goals in 366 appearances, including 11 goals last season when he was far from an ever-present.

I hated it when he played against my team, as I thought he was bound to score, but what I always liked about him was that he never once moaned about being on the bench, or about the money, and never talked up a potential transfer to some other club – he just got on with playing football (Four goals as a sub against Forest sticks in the mind for me, never mind the Champions League Final winner). It’s rare these days to see that kind of behaviour, all you see is the likes of Ashley Cole touting themselves about.

It’s good to see that Man U are rewarding him with a position at the club; in the times of Bosman transfers, unscrupulous agents and other unsavoury aspects of football it’s good to see a bright spark of loyalty.

It does mean that Man U are even shorter of strikers though; Saha is clearly not the answer, Smith and Rossi have gone and if Rooney and Ronaldo are going to be absent for any length of time again this season there is going to be a problem. There is still time to for Ferguson to buy, and it would be ironic if Mr Loyalty was replaced with someone like say, Nicolas Anelka?

Are Wayne Rooney’s feet made of glass?

Posted on August 12th, 2007 in Injuries, Premiership by Left back

No, despite his new injury, I can confirm his feet are not made of glass. They are, in fact, made from fine bone china.

I know it’s wrong…

Posted on August 8th, 2007 in Injuries, Premiership by Left back

…but it’s really hard not to laugh at Lucas Neill being out yet again with an injury for West Ham. Since they decided to pay him £60,000 a week he’s been more or less constantly crocked.

Still, he’s no Matthew Upson who’s set to miss 6 months of the season after rupturing his anterior thumbnail hanging a picture at home. Honestly. No, really. Ok then, maybe not. He’ll miss 6 months with something though, just you wait and see.

Next Page »