A few weeks ago Arsenal captain Thierry Henry said that he wished football referees would be as communicative and open as rugby referees. Yesterday I watched Ireland play Australia at Lansdowne Road.
At one point an Aussie and an Irish guy got into a bit of handbagging style argy-bargy. The ref called the two players over, with their captains and said, “You and you got into fisticuffs and ended up behind the goal. 10 minute sin-bin for both of you. Off you go.”
He then spoke to another Australian saying “You came running over to get involved for no good reason. 10 minutes, yellow card, off you go.”

There wasn’t a murmur of dissent from either captain or from any of the players sent to the sin bin. As the game got a bit fractious the ref called the two captains over and told them to talk to their team to cut it out. When an Australian questioned the ref’s decision he moved the play forward 10 metres. No Australian opened his mouth from then on. There was certainly no swearing at the official whose decisions can be heard at all times through his mic/headset.
At all times the referee was totally in control and his decisions were accepted without question. Is there any reason why this can’t happen in football?
Of course there would be an adjustment period when players were getting booked all over the place as they would have to fight their natural instinct to shout and roar disapproval at every decision but even the most stupid of players would learn in the end. Open your mouth and you’re booked, possibly sent off.
FIFA and UEFA talk about the need for players to respect the rules and although we all complain about referees the fact that the two main associations in the game do nothing to ensure the referee’s decisions are final is a huge part of the problem. How often do we see a penalty awarded and players crowd the referee to complain or barrack him or say “I didn’t touch him ref, honest!”
How often has a referee changed his mind because of that? Exactly.
It really would be very simple to implement a similar code of conduct in football. In fact, it already exists but for years players have been allowed question the integrity of match officials, to call them names, to insult and swear at them and the officials have been unable to do anything about it.
Graham Poll was pilloried last week by Everton’s management and fans for sending James McFadden off but the fact is McFadden called the referee a ‘fucking cheat’ and Poll, however much we have trouble with him, did the right thing. McFadden’s piss poor attempt at excusing himself was shown up as exactly that when neither he or the club decided to appeal the red card.
I think Thierry Henry has a point when he says football officials can be more like rugby officials who talk to the captain, who explain their decisions and are accountable because everyone can hear what he says.
At the same time though football players have to be more like rugby players and accept the decisions of the match officials without questioning them constantly. Can it work in football? It would be a massive change but surely one for the better.
Your thoughts please.